Built for peace of mind: Why policy-based investments deserve a place in modern retirement fund governance

by | 14,Oct,2026 | Liberty Group, Q4 2026, Special Feature

George Brown

In a complex investment landscape, retirement fund stakeholders face a difficult balancing act. Members want strong long-term returns, protection from market uncertainty, transparent governance and cost efficiency. Regulators expect prudent oversight. Employers seek sustainable outcomes. Yet one principle remains constant: investment structures should create financial confidence rather than concern.

This is where policy-based investments can play an important role.

Through life insurers’ balance sheets, policy-based investments have formed part of South African retirement funds for decades. They offer a distinctive combination of governance, administration and risk management characteristics that can support what many trustees ultimately seek: peace of mind.

Looking beyond performance

Trustees are rightly focused on investment performance. However, retirement outcomes are influenced by far more than returns alone.

Investment governance, operational resilience, member behaviour, liquidity management, portfolio implementation and remaining invested through market stress all contribute to long-term success.

A policy-based investment structure combines investment management with an insurance policy wrapper. This allows retirement funds to access broader and deeper investment markets while benefiting from additional governance and operational mechanisms within a life licensed environment.

The result is often a more structured framework, with defined responsibilities, stronger oversight and long-term alignment between investment objectives and implementation.

This shifts the discussion from asking, “What return did we achieve?” to the important question, “How are we helping members achieve retirement security?”

Simplicity in a complex world

One of the greatest challenges facing retirement funds is complexity.

Global research continues to show that when investment choices become overwhelming, decision quality often deteriorates. Vanguard’s 2026 analysis found that member behaviour increasingly favours simplified investment solutions rather than large menus of options. Simplicity often improves engagement.

For trustees, policy-based investments can support simplicity through:

  • Consolidated investment reporting
  • Streamlined governance
  • Integrated implementation of investments
  • Reduced operational complexity
  • Monitoring of investment objectives

Simplicity should never be confused with oversimplification. Rather, it means creating investment structures that are understandable, transparent and easier to govern effectively.

Creating greater confidence

Investment markets will always be uncertain.

Interest rates move, geopolitical events occur and markets periodically experience significant volatility. Trustees cannot eliminate these risks, but they can seek structures that help manage them appropriately.

Policy-based investments can provide peace of mind through features such as:

  • Contractual frameworks
  • Formal governance
  • Access to smoothing or capital
    protection where appropriate
  • Strong oversight under insurance legislation
  • Long-term asset-liability  management

Research from a J.P. Morgan 2025 survey found that among plan sponsors expressing high confidence in asset allocation outcomes, 94% utilised a default investment arrangement based on structured investment solutions. The common theme is not the specific product, but the value of disciplined, policy-driven investment design. 1

Certainty is not just about guarantees but rather creating confidence the investments will continue functioning as intended (and hence as expected by investors) across markets.

  • Bringing humanity back to investing

Members may experience retirement differently to how retirement funds portray it.

Members worry about whether they will have enough income at retirement. They worry about preserving purchasing power. They worry about becoming dependent on their families.

Recent South African research highlights the scale of this challenge. Only around 10% of South Africans believe they will be able to retire comfortably at age 60, reflecting deep concerns about retirement readiness and financial security.2

This is why governance decisions should ultimately be measured against a human outcome:

Will this improve members’ chances of achieving a dignified retirement?

Policy-based investments can contribute positively by helping trustees focus on consistent implementation, long-term discipline and improved member experience rather than short-term market noise.

Built for peace of mind

Retirement funds exist to help members achieve financial security after decades of work. Investment structures should therefore do more than provide access to markets. They should create confidence, support disciplined decision-making and help trustees discharge their fiduciary responsibilities effectively.

In a world characterised by uncertainty, the most valuable investment solution may not be the most complex.

It may simply be the one that delivers what members and trustees need most: humanity in design, simplicity in execution and certainty in governance.

Because ultimately, retirement investing should be built for peace of mind.

1 J.P. Morgan Asset Management (2025), Defined Contribution Plan Sponsor Survey. [am.jpmorgan.com]

2Taylor, J. (2026), Retirement Planning: Restoring Humanity, Simplicity and Certainty (citing South African retirement readiness research showing only ~10% expect to retire comfortably). [Unpublished]

Louis Theron
+ posts